Performance Comparison Of Fuses And Circuit Breakers

Jun 23, 2022

Leave a message

Comparing the protection performance of fuses and circuit breakers, the circuit breakers are described in terms of non-selective type and selective type, respectively.

 

First, the fuse.

 

(1) The main advantages and characteristics of the fuse.

 

① Good selectivity. As long as the rated current of the fuse link of the upper and lower fuse meets the national standard and the overcurrent selection ratio specified by the IEC standard of 1.6:1, that is, the rated current of the upper fuse is not less than 1.6 times the value of the lower level, it is considered that the upper and lower levels can selectively Cut off the fault current;

 

②Good current limiting characteristics and high breaking capacity;

 

③The relative size is small;

 

④The price is cheap.

 

(2) The main shortcomings and weaknesses of the fuse.

 

①The fuse must be replaced after a fuse failure;

 

②Single protection function, only one over-current inverse time characteristic, used for overload, short circuit and ground fault protection;

 

③When one phase is blown, the three-phase motor will cause the undesirable consequences of two-phase operation. Of course, a fuse with an alarm signal can be used to make up for it. One-phase blown can disconnect the three-phase;

 

④Remote control cannot be realized, it needs to be combined with electric knife switch and switch.

 

Second, non-selective circuit breakers.

 

(1) Main advantages and characteristics.

 

①After the fault is disconnected, it can be reset manually without replacing the components, unless the large short-circuit current needs to be repaired;

 

②The two protection functions of long-time release and instantaneous current release with inverse time limit are used for overload and short-circuit protection respectively, and each perform its own duties;

 

③The live operating mechanism can realize remote control.

 

(2) Main shortcomings and weaknesses.

 

①It is difficult to achieve selective cut-off between upper and lower non-selective circuit breakers. When the fault current is large, the upper and lower circuit breakers are easily disconnected instantly;

 

②The relative price is slightly higher;

 

③Some circuit breakers have small breaking capacity. For example, if a circuit breaker with a small rated current is installed near a large-capacity transformer, the breaking capacity is insufficient. Now products with high breaking capacity can be satisfied, but the price is higher.

 

Third, choose a circuit breaker.

 

(1) Main advantages and characteristics.

 

①It has the advantages of the above-mentioned non-selective circuit breakers;

 

②It has a variety of protection functions, including long time delay, instantaneous, short time delay and ground fault (including zero sequence current and residual current protection) protection, which can realize overload, open circuit delay, large short circuit current instantaneous action and ground fault protection respectively, High protection sensitivity, easy to adjust various parameters, easy to meet various protection requirements of power distribution lines. In addition, it can also have a cascade protection function, which has better selective action performance.

 

③Most of the current products have the characteristics of intelligence. In addition to the protection function, they also have power measurement, fault recording, communication excuses, etc., to achieve centralized monitoring and management of power distribution devices and systems.

 

(2) The main problem.

 

(1) The price is very high, and it can only be used at the first end of the distribution line and particularly important places;

 

②The size is larger.

 

Send Inquiry
Contact us if have any question

You can either contact us via phone, email or online form below. Our specialist will contact you back shortly.

Contact now!